COMPARISON | Eye Shadow Pencils
Let's get started!
Jordana 12 Hr Made To Last Eyeshadow Pencil
"Eternal White" |
- Pros: Very creamy, pigmented, blends easy, very inexpensive $3.99 at most Walgreens, 0.10 oz of product
- Cons: Creases after application so you need to blend it out with your fingers, limited color selection (8 colors, but 4 are matte and neutral!), needs to be sharpened
- Rating: 4.0/5
- Pros: Inexpensive $4.59 at nyx.com, Ulta and some Targets, wide range of colors from neutrals to bright colors, pigmented, 0.18 oz of product, doesn't crease
- Cons: Tugs at the eye when applying, very dry and hard formula, packaging breaks easily, needs to be sharpened
- Rating: 2.5/5
- Pros: Twist up applicator(Don't need to sharpen), doesn't crease, comes with a smudger
- Cons: Tugs at the eye when applying, drier formula, only 0.018 oz of product, limited color selection (only 6 in permanent line)
- Rating: 3.0/5
- Pros: Very creamy, pigmented, easy to apply, doesn't crease, inexpensive about $4.49 at stores, 0.11 oz of product, color is opaque
- Cons: Limited color selection (9 in permanent line), needs to be sharpened
- Rating: 4.5/5
- Pros: Very pigmented, wide color selection (16 in permanent line), doesn't need to be sharpened, inexpensive $4.49 at nyx.com, and Ulta
- Cons: CREASES!! within a couple of hours, Doesn't last on the eyes
- Rating: 2.0/5
Palladio Shadow & Liner Herbal Crayon
- Pros: Very pigmented, Extremely creamy, good color selection (12 in permanent line), easy to apply, doesn't crease, nice cooling sensation when applying to lid
- Cons: Needs to be sharpened, messy to sharpen
- Rating: 4.5/5
Ones I Recommend:
- Jordana 12 HR Made To Last Eyeshadow Pencil
- Rimmel Scandaleyes Eye Shadow Stick *Favorite*
- Palladio Shadow & Liner Herbal Crayon
Ones I Would Avoid:
- NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil
- NYX Glam Shadow Stick *Worst*
- Maybelline Master Smoky Long Wearing Shadow Pencil
Comments